If you’re tired of censorship and dystopian threats against civil liberties, subscribe to Reclaim The Net.
Irish authorities have moved ahead with extensive legislation aimed at tackling “misinformation,” yet they have not examined whether such measures might undermine free expression. The Department responsible for communications, media, and environmental policy has acknowledged that no analysis has been carried out to assess the consequences for free speech.
Responding to a media query from Gript, the Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications plainly admitted: “The Department has not undertaken any analysis or research on the potential impact of mis/disinformation laws on free speech.”
Despite this lack of evaluation, the government continues to defend its strategy. Speaking outside Government Buildings, Taoiseach (Prime Minster) Micheál Martin insisted the effort to curb online falsehoods is justified, arguing that some speech doesn’t merit protection. “It’s not freedom of speech, really, when it’s just a blatant lie and untruth, which can create a lot of public disquiet, as we have seen,” he said.
Martin downplayed the idea that regulating disinformation represents any serious threat to expressive freedoms, stating: “There are very strong protections in our constitution and in our laws and freedom of speech.” He added, “I wouldn’t overstate the impact on clamping down on blatant lies online as a sort of incursion or an undermining of freedom of speech.”
When pressed on whether the absence of impact studies was irresponsible, Martin referenced a recent RTÉ radio segment about social media claims related to a shooting in Carlow. “There was a researcher on identifying the blatant misinformation on truths and lies surrounding what happened in Carlow,” he said. “So I do think it’s absolutely important that government focuses on this issue.”
He condemned online narratives surrounding the incident, claiming they spread false claims about fatalities. “People were saying on social media that seven people had been killed, that people had been shot that were not shot,” he said. “The level of misinformation on Sunday was quite shocking.” For Martin, this incident exemplifies why authorities must step in: “You can’t just ignore that and say, well, we don’t have to do anything about that.”
He also dismissed concerns that regulating misinformation poses any real threat to civil liberties. “I believe that people are overstating the dangers to freedom of speech in efforts to address misinformation and untruths,” he said. “And I think we have to do that too.”
If you’re tired of censorship and dystopian threats against civil liberties, subscribe to Reclaim The Net.
The post Irish Government Admits No Free Speech Impact Assessment for “Misinformation” Laws appeared first on Reclaim The Net.
Be the first to comment